Summary
Renal clearance procedures were performed on adult mixed-breed dogs with a wide range of renal function. Endogenous creatinine clearance was computed after analyzing plasma and urine for creatinine by use of 2 methods, PAP and kinetic Jaffe. For 20-minute clearance procedures, [14C]inulin clearance was measured simultaneously with endogenous creatinine clearance.
For 111 twenty-minute clearance procedures performed on 24 dogs, [14C]inulin clearance was highly correlated with creatinine clearance for both methods of creatinine analysis (R2 = 0.979 for [14C]inulin-PAP; R2 = 0.943 for [14C]inulin-Jaffe). The absolute values for PAP and [14C]inulin clearance were nearly the same (PAP-to-[14C]inulin clearance ratio = 1.03 ± 0.08), but those for Jaffe clearance were substantially less than those for [14C]inulin clearance (Jaffe-to-[14C]inulin clearance ratio = 0.88 ± 0.10).
The Jaffe-to-[14C]inulin clearance ratio was inversely correlated with degree of renal function (R2= 0.464), whereas the PAP-to-[14C]inulin clearance ratio was not correlated with degree of renal function (R2 = 0.060). Thus, Jaffe-determined creatinine clearance varied, in relation to [14C]inulin clearance, depending on degree of renal function.
In 4 clinically normal dogs, 20-minute and 24-hour sample collections analyzed by use of the PAP method gave clearance values significantly greater, for both periods, than did Jaffe analyses. The PAP-determined creatinine clearance values were less than, but not significantly different from 20-minute exogenous creatinine clearance values determined 10 days after 24-hour collections.
For 20-minute and 24-hour collections, the difference in clearance values between the PAP and Jaffe methods was attributable mostly to lower plasma creatinine values for the PAP method (mean ± SEM, plasma PAP-to-Jaffe ratio = 0.798 ± 0.053). However, urine creatinine values also were less by use of the PAP method (urine PAP-to-Jaffe ratio = 0.943 ± 0.103).
We conclude that PAP-determined creatinine clearance reliably measured glomerular filtration rate during 20-minute collections, and probably during 24-hour collections as well. By contrast, Jaffe-determined creatinine clearance underestimated glomerular filtration rate by a variable amount.
